Chris:
First of all, welcome to our Forum. You purchased your first Slot at a very reasonable price, considering the small missing parts.
It is a Jennings "4 Star Chief" model, but what the exact model is, that it is called, I am not sure. It is one that I haven't seen too
often. It could very likely be an operator revamp. The lower front is wood, instead of the usual casting, and the jackpot is bolted
on from the outside front, and is flat-formed steel, rather than a casting. The reason that your case & mechanism serial numbers
do not match, is also most likely due to an operator 'switcharoo'. Or could have also been done by a later owner. Don't shy away
from the machine, just because of that, as it is an odd-ball model. Maybe one of our other members, with more knowledge with
the Jennings models than I, can shed some more light on the subject.
The photo that I am showing below, is the same model as yours, with a couple of slight differences. The lower wood front, has
cherries, instead of the stars that were on yours. I'm not sure if the cherries are correct, or if the restorer decided to put them
there, as there is a Jennings "Cherry Bell" model, but this isn't it. Therefore the stars may be correct, being as yours shows the
signs of them being there. Your Indian decal, may also be correct, as there are no signs of mounting holes from a cast chief head.
You are also fortunate to have an original back door, and coin box. Hopefully it plays, and pays well. I would definitely strip the
grey paint from the base-board. Good luck with your restoration, should you decide to tackle it.
Bill